Skip to content
CouncilSoft
Local SEO

How to Choose an SEO Company: 12 Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Twelve questions to ask before you hire, the red flags that should end the conversation, and what a useful monthly report looks like.

CouncilSoft team

6 MIN READ

Flat navy illustration of a clipboard checklist with a magnifying glass and a red map pin.
FIG. 1Flat navy illustration of a clipboard checklist with a magnifying glass and a red map pin.
Quick answer

Choose an SEO company that explains its work in plain English, shows real examples, reports on calls and leads instead of vague scores, and leaves you as the owner of your Google profile, website and every login. Walk away from anyone who promises a ranking, sells bundles of links or locks you into a contract you can't leave.

Most business owners hire an SEO company the same way they'd hire a contractor they can't supervise: on trust. You can't easily check the work, the results take months, and the jargon makes every pitch sound the same. That's exactly why the questions you ask up front matter so much.

This guide gives you twelve questions to ask, the answers to listen for, the red flags that should end the conversation and what good reporting looks like.

Start with what you need

Before you call anyone, be clear about the job. A roofer in Doylestown who gets most calls from Google Maps needs local SEO: the Google profile, reviews, listings and town pages. An online store shipping across the country needs national SEO. Plenty of agencies do one well and the other poorly, so ask which kind of client makes up most of their work.

Do a little homework first

Ten minutes of checking saves an hour of sales calls. Before you talk to anyone:

  • Look them up on Google. A company selling local SEO should have a complete profile of its own, with real reviews and replies to them.
  • Read their reviews closely. Look for specifics, such as the trade, the town and what changed, not just five stars and "great to work with."
  • Check that they publish something useful. Articles, guides or at least clear service pages show how they think and how they write.
  • See if prices are public. Not every good company publishes prices, but a rough starting point tells you quickly whether a call is worth your time.

12 questions to ask

About the work

  1. What will you do in the first 90 days? You want a concrete answer: a profile audit, listing cleanup, specific pages, a review process. "Optimize your online presence" isn't an answer.
  2. Which examples can you share from businesses like ours? Ask for work in a similar trade or a similar kind of town. Be wary of results with the names removed and no way to check them.
  3. Do you follow Google's Search Essentials? These are Google's published rules for websites. Any reputable company will say yes without hesitating, and should be able to explain what that means for your site.
  4. How do you get reviews? The right answer is a steady, honest request to every customer. Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's rule on fake reviews lets it fine businesses that buy or fabricate them, so any talk of "adding reviews" should end the call.
  5. Who writes the content, and do we approve it? You should see every post, page and profile change before it goes live, at least for the first few months.
  6. Will you tell us every change you make? Google suggests asking exactly this. A good company keeps a log.

About ownership

  1. Who owns our Google Business Profile? You should be the primary owner. Google lets owners add managers, who can do the work but can't remove users or delete the profile. That's the access an agency needs.
  2. Who owns the domain, website, hosting and analytics? You, in your business's name, with your own logins. The agency gets access, not ownership.
  3. What happens to our listings if we part ways? Directory listings built for you should come with their logins, so you can keep them up to date without the agency.

About reporting and the contract

  1. How do you measure success? Listen for calls, form fills, direction requests and map positions across the towns you serve. Be wary of reports built on traffic alone or scores invented by a software company.
  2. How often will we hear from you, and from whom? A monthly report plus a named point of contact who answers within a business day is a reasonable bar.
  3. What are the contract terms, and how do we leave? Get the length, the notice period and any exit fees in writing before you sign.

Red flags that should end the call

  • Anyone who promises a ranking. Google's guidance on hiring an SEO is blunt: no one can promise the top spot, and if a company says it can, find someone else.
  • Bundles of links or "submission to 1,000 directories." Google tells owners to avoid providers that talk about link schemes. These packages can get a site penalized, and cleaning up afterward is slow.
  • They insist on owning your accounts. If the agency creates your Google profile under its own login or registers your domain in its name, leaving becomes painful.
  • A secret method. Good SEO isn't secret. If they can't explain what they'll do in plain words, they may not be doing much.
  • A long lock-in with stiff exit fees. A company confident in its work doesn't need to trap you.
  • A price far below the market. In an Ahrefs survey of 439 SEO providers, the average local SEO retainer was $1,557 a month. A $99 plan can't include much hands-on work. Our guide to what local SEO costs breaks down the numbers.

What typical SEO pricing looks like

Use these figures to sanity-check a quote, not to pick the cheapest one.

What was measured Figure
Providers charging a monthly retainer 78.2%
Average local SEO retainer $1,557 a month
Most common monthly price band $501 to $1,000
Average hourly rate $111 an hour
Providers charging $150 an hour or less 90%

Source: Ahrefs survey of 439 SEO providers (page updated August 2024). Figures as of October 2026.

What good reporting looks like

A useful monthly report fits on a page or two and answers three questions: what did you do, what changed and what's next. Look for:

  • A list of completed work. Posts published, pages added, listings fixed, reviews replied to.
  • Map positions across your area. A single ranking number hides the truth, since a business can sit in the top three at its front door and vanish two miles away. Our article on how the map pack picks its top three explains why.
  • Actions from your Google profile. Calls, website clicks and direction requests, compared with last month and last year.
  • Review growth. New reviews, average rating and how quickly each got a reply. If reviews are a weak spot, see how to get more Google reviews.
  • Plain English. If you need a glossary to read the report, it isn't written for you.

How we answer these questions

We'd rather you ask all twelve. In short: you stay the owner of your Google profile, domain and every login, and we work as a manager. You approve changes before they go live. Listings we build come with their logins. Every month you get a plain-English report covering the work, your map positions across your service area and the calls and clicks your profile brought in. Our starting prices are public on the pricing page.

What to do next

The easiest way to judge any SEO company is to see how they assess your business before you pay anything. Our free visibility audit looks at your Google profile, map positions, listings and website, and tells you plainly what we'd fix first. Take it to compare against other quotes if you like.

FAQ

Should I give an SEO company my Google Business Profile login?

No. Add them as a manager from your profile's settings. You stay the owner, they can do the work, and you can remove their access in a couple of clicks if you part ways.

Is a local SEO company better than a national one?

For a business that serves nearby towns, local experience matters more than size. A company that knows how the map pack works and knows your area will usually do more with the same budget.

How long should an SEO contract be?

Long enough to see results, short enough that you're not trapped. Local SEO takes three to six months to show its full effect, but any contract should spell out how you leave and what you keep.

What should an SEO company report each month?

What they did, what changed and what happens next, tied to things you care about: calls, form fills, direction requests and where you show up across your service area.

CouncilSoft team · Local SEO and web design, CouncilSoft

We run local SEO, Google Business Profiles and websites for businesses in Bucks County, Montgomery County, Philadelphia and the Main Line.

See what Google sees, free.

Tell us your business name and we'll put together a full visibility report.

Free · No commitment · No jargon